« Facebook is the opposite of what I'm looking for |
Main
| Longevity pill on track; FCC unlocks phones; 'That's Amore,' blues links; Chris Walken cooking video; Justice Roberts, human; »
August 1, 2007
Facebook, Day 2
Newsies Steve Outing (Looking for the anti Facebook) and Ryan Sholin (Find yourself a nice comfortable niche and sell it like blueberry pancakes) both seized on my lead on yesterday's Facebook post as an argument for niche networks.
Somewhere, I like to think, there is or will be a network comprising only those who can find it. And when I finally stumble in there, they’ll say, “We’ve been waiting for you.”
It’s not Facebook, a “social network” of 30 million or so.
I confess I was thinking less concretely, more like The Journey to the East.
It was actually the last thing I wrote, but sometimes the conclusion at the end of thinking and writing a piece is actually the natural lead. I never know how it will come out.
Dave Winer today puts one of my concerns about Facebook into more technical terms:
The great thing about the Internet was and is that it's the platform without a platform vendor. That's why it has been the engine of growth and innovation for so long, over thirty years now. There's no entity with eminent domain to foreclose on a developer's relationship with customers. And none of us are incentivized to care for a platform's garden in the same way we are with the community garden....
Facebook is a platform vendor, obviously, and when one develops a Facebook app, one is willingly climbing into the trunk, which has a lock, and only one entity has the key, the platform vendor.
From our side: Broken links: bad. All Facebook links are broken if you haven't joined the crowd.
Bonus link: Travel guru Arthur Frommer blogs a metaphor for Facebook: What's it like to cruise on one of those new ships carrying 3,000 passengers and more?
Posted by Sheila Lennon
at 9:20 AM | Permalink
For the record, I really am enjoying Facebook. I didn't adopt (like many of us, I think) until the apps opened up -- that changed everything.
Let me put it this way: Facebook is where all my little niche networks intertwine and make connections.
Media bloggers? Got 'em. Online news pros? Got 'em. Newsroom pals? Got 'em. Old friends I haven't seen since high school? Got the ones that matter.
The closed-ness of Facebook means that the FOAFs can't just walk right in and see my full profile, so instead of one giant web, it works much more like a network of tiny little interlocking webs.
Obviously the tangent I'm off on doesn't provide any defense for unlinkability and roach motel data worries, but I'm not terribly worried about that in the first place. Facebook isn't the only place I'm connected to most of these people.
Posted by: Ryan on August 1, 2007 10:34 AM
Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published.