Recent Comments

Elisa Camahort on When women who can count don't count: Office 2.0 conference speakers 98 percent male

Sheila on When women who can count don't count: Office 2.0 conference speakers 98 percent male

Zoli Erdos on When women who can count don't count: Office 2.0 conference speakers 98 percent male

Ismael Ghalimi on When women who can count don't count: Office 2.0 conference speakers 98 percent male



To comment on any posting, click on the word 'Comments' at the end of the item.

« Ann Coulter on Chafee: 'They Shot the Wrong Lincoln' | Main | We want Deion! Games for a rainy day; Cell phone reviews »

September 2, 2006

When women who can count don't count: Office 2.0 conference speakers 98 percent male

Testosteroni: The Office 2.0 Conference (all your programs on the Web, like GMail) promises a wide ranging group of visionaries and industry leaders -- 53 men and one woman. Reactions:

Holy sausage party and Okay...rather than just complain... -- Tara Hunt

What will work - Shelley Powers

Your Balls Are in Your Court -- Jeneane Sessum

Stowe Boyd parrots the line, then does a mea culpa after his friend Jeneane calls him out.

Validating Shelley Powers or more middle aged white guys tethered together -- alan herrell - the head lemur

Conference organizers make my head explode -- Elisa Camahort

Broader: Where Are The Women Redux: Supreme Court, Office 2.0 Lacking Women

The event's organizer, Ismael Ghalimi, attempts to explain: About a Chap. I think he's saying he just wanted to have fun with his friends, and none of his friends are girls.

The fourth-grader in our family says that, too.

But he's not a CEO organizing a public event, with high-powered sponsors, a slick website and a claim to cornering the "visionaries." This "poor little me" post deserves the label Shelley gives it: Clueless.

The point? In the future, perhaps conference organizers will look beyond the comfy crowd of folks just like themselves, lest they be Ismaeled.

Resources (to avoid that fate):

Smart women speakers
.

Speakers wiki: Add yourself if you're willing to go on the circuit.

(I just might. I do these speaker gigs on blogging panels sometimes, including at an upcoming AP conference Sept. 30. Journalism -- aware that its readers/users and half the population are female -- seeks out and invites women out of the blue.)

Posted by Sheila Lennon  at 9:33 AM | Permalink

Comments

Sheila,

Thanks for creating a word out of my poor condition. That's quite an honor. And I agree with you, let's hope that it serves as a lesson to future conference organizers. Being Ismaeled is no fun...

Take care
-Ismael

Posted by: Ismael Ghalimi on September 2, 2006 1:10 PM

Sheila,

Adding yourself to the Speakers Wiki is a good move. So is registering for whatever you are interested in and feel qualified for.  'Cause that's exactly how this conference is being organized:  The speaker list is not by invitation,  the organizer called for speaker applications here.

With open registration if you don't sign up, you can't really complain of being excluded ...

Posted by: Zoli Erdos on September 2, 2006 1:32 PM

Ismael, you're wearing it well. Thanks for stopping by.

Zoli, you've been saying the same thing on other blogs, so by now you have heard many times that the speaker list was assembled largely by invitation, and that subsequently having a form on the web site of a conference known only to friends of Ismael is hardly openness.

Your own comment at Frank Paynter's Listics above reveals the "membership" of this circle:

"But also consider the speaker’s background:
- mostly CEO’s of startups in related areas
- analyst / press types
Some will fly in, many are from the SF Bay Area.. combine those factors and you get the demographic we currently have."

Hey, that's the "wide ranging group of visionaries and industry leaders" you're touting?

This self-selecting demographic is an echo chamber. Since the conference involves apps that all of us will be using, why wouldn't those sharing information seek a variety of perspectives and ideas? You want to know what we really need? (I need flexible tools to make my ideas for a next-wave news and information site.)

Without such input we get narrow clunky apps and failed startups: What they can make (and think they can make money with) has to do what we want to do or nobody will care.

I see that more women have now been added, and indie podcasts will be welcomed. As damage control, it may help.

Finally... "you can't complain" -- as you've seen -- will only spawn defenses of the right to complain loudly and at length about anything. It's a condescending "shut up," and that never gets a good reception, and never gets you off the hook.

Posted by: Sheila on September 3, 2006 6:06 AM

Thanks for pointing out the invite aspect. I was about to leave a PS to my other comment about his blog being full of "thank yous" to folks making introductions to speakers for him.

Nothing wrong with that, absolutely standard. Just don't trot out the patronizing "if you don't sign up, you can't really complain" argument. (Which of course wasn't Ismael's argument...to be very clear.)

Posted by: Elisa Camahort on September 3, 2006 10:34 AM


my passport photo
blogging since 2002
garden blogs
archived headlines



Sheila Lennon
is features & interactive producer of projo.com, the Web site of
The Providence (R.I.) Journal

Rhode Island
Library Lookup:

Updated
See a book on Amazon,
reserve it at the library!
PPL

Drag the 'PPL' link above to your browser's personal toolbar folder or links toolbar; click PPL from a book's page at Amazon, etc., to search the library catalog and request the book

Subterranean Homepage News:
May « Jun 2008        
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          

Active projo blogs

7 to 7 News Blog
Politics Blog
Subterranean Homepage News
Sports Blog
Hoops Blog
PatsBlog
RunningBlog
SoxBlog
High School Sports
Bruins Blog
CarsBlog
Off Beat
Fishing: HotBytes
Garden Blog
Fantasy Sports Blog
Biz Blog

Guest blog
Sailing

Blogroll

Indexes & Group blogs

Greater R.I. Blogs
Providence Geeks
Unmediated
CyberJournalist: News Weblogs
BoingBoing
Ms. Magazine blogroll
What She Said!
Southern New England bloggers (Gone, but here are its links)
blogdex
Metafilter
Slashdot
Slashdot Politics
Blog Sisters
Shell Extension City
Daypop Top 40 Links
Lost Remote
Mirror project
I Want Media
Blogcritics
Microcontent News
E-Media Tidbits
Through the Viewfinder
Daily Rotation
news we can use
Popdex
Blog Search Engine

Bloggers
Jim Romenesko
Shelley Powers
Doc Searls
JD Lasica
Tom Mangan
Tom Matrullo
Tom Shugart
Kevin Moore
Rebecca Blood
Cory Doctorow
David Weinberger
Lou Josephs
Dan Gillmor
Making Light
Jeneane Sessum
Liz Donovan
Robot Wisdom
Grow-a-brain
J-Walk
Dave Winer
"Salam Pax"
Baghdad Burning
Ft. Boise
Henry Gould
Wayne Robins
FollowMe Here
kalilily time
Judy Watt
Obscure Store
plep
wood s lot
The Shifted Librarian

NASA image links
Multimedia gallery
Image exchange (search)
JSC Digital Image