Recent Comments

To comment on any posting, click on the word 'Comments' at the end of the item.

« Neil Young CD to protest war, urge impeachment | Main | Providence Geeks meet Wednesday night; Reporter, daughter blog from New Orleans relief kitchen; 34.5 million weblogs now »

April 17, 2006

Guest blogger Liz Petow: College Admission: It's Over

lizpetow.jpg
Liz Petow
When I received my first flat little white envelope, I was devastated. I wasn't upset, however, because the school had not been my first choice school. I hadn't wanted to go there. I was upset because the thin envelope meant I hadn't gotten in. And I really thought I would.

Last fall, after digging through information on all the colleges I could think of and sifting through all the "hottest" schools lists, I compiled a list of schools in which I was at least somewhat interested. Over the months, I whittled it down to seven schools, and after spending hours upon hours on admissions websites, gallons of gas on college visits, and too much money on headache medicine, the time has come and gone for admissions decisions.

It's over -- for most of us. By April 1, most colleges and universities have delivered letters of acceptance or rejection to their many applicants. For many of my peers and for myself, it was a mildly traumatizing end to an excruciating wait.

As many of my classmates and I have noticed, admissions seem to be unusually competitive this year. No one expects to get into every school, but when students get into few of their choices, it's surprising. Everyone I know seems to have gotten an unexpected amount of thin white envelopes.

We're not imagining it:

My theory is there had to have been an increase in births in 1988. Whether or not that is true, nearly every college I received an acceptance or a rejection letter from boasted their significant increase in applicants this year. Columbia received 19,730 applications this year, a 9% increase from last year and a record high. 20,300 students applied to the University of Pennsylvania this year, an 8% increase. Even the University of Vermont saw an increase to 18,000 applicants, a record high for the university. Harvard, however, saw its applicant pool hold steady, declining from 22,796 applications last year to 22,719 this year.

Others attribute these changes to a too-easy admissions process that encourages students to apply to more colleges without much interest in the schools. The Common Application allows you to compile one application, photocopy it, and send it to as many schools as will accept it. Or do the entire process online. Many colleges also offer even easier applications. VIP applications are offered to some students from many universities: They permit students to disregard the application fee or even the application essay. Next year, the Common App will do away with the paper application, making it so that all students, with the click of a mouse on a check box, can send their applications off to as many colleges as they desire. I had thought my seven schools was an excessive number, until a coworker told me she applied to fifteen.

With this many applicants, it is impossible for colleges to accept every qualified student. I think this generated a lot of headaches and heartache problems, with many being rejected or waitlisted to their top-choice, incredibly prestigious schools. Yale's acceptance rate dropped to 8.6%. Dartmouth accepted a record low of 15.4% applicants. Brown took only 13.8% of their never before seen 18,313 applicants.

When barely 9% of an applicant pool can be accepted, it's impossible for anyone to feel confident about being accepted by their first-choice school. The prospect of not attending Harvard or Yale next fall may be be a horrifying thought for some, but it is the reality for most of us. College websites and message boards, such as collegeconfidential.com have been bombarded by the wails of students who believe their lives have ended now that the Ivies don't want them.

But, there are many options left that can give any student a quality education if that is what they want. The "public Ivies," which include UC-Berkeley and UNC-Chapel Hill, provide academic opportunities to their students equivalent to any private Ivy League school. Many small liberal arts schools, which are scattered throughout the country, may be a better fit than a large Ivy League school, where huge classes may be taught primarily by graduate assistants. Public universities, even those that haven't gained the title "public ivy," are usually more financially feasible for the average student, and many offer honors programs that can enrich the curriculum of especially successful applicants.

When students with Advance Placement and International Baccalaureate backgrounds, 2000+ SAT scores, and extracurricular success enter, not the halls of Harvard or Brown, but rather those of state universities and small liberal arts schools, the schools will benefit from their presence.

For those of us who have had it ingrained in us that we're exceptional our entire academic careers, these rejections are blows to our egos, and it's tempting to feel we've wasted our time and energy working toward a seemingly unattainable goal. But, at this point, I'm just happy I can say it's over.

Liz Petow, co-editor-in-chief of The Bengal Beat at St. Mary's Academy, Bay View, in Riverside, R.I., will be attending the University of Vermont next year.

Related: Stanford Daily: Seniors post college rejection letters at local high school

Posted by Sheila Lennon  at 6:36 AM | Permalink


my passport photo
blogging since 2002
garden blogs
archived headlines



Sheila Lennon
is features & interactive producer of projo.com, the Web site of
The Providence (R.I.) Journal

Rhode Island
Library Lookup:

Updated
See a book on Amazon,
reserve it at the library!
PPL

Drag the 'PPL' link above to your browser's personal toolbar folder or links toolbar; click PPL from a book's page at Amazon, etc., to search the library catalog and request the book

Subterranean Homepage News:
May « Jun 2008        
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          

Active projo blogs

7 to 7 News Blog
Politics Blog
Subterranean Homepage News
Sports Blog
Hoops Blog
PatsBlog
RunningBlog
SoxBlog
High School Sports
Bruins Blog
CarsBlog
Off Beat
Fishing: HotBytes
Garden Blog
Fantasy Sports Blog
Biz Blog

Guest blog
Sailing

Blogroll

Indexes & Group blogs

Greater R.I. Blogs
Providence Geeks
Unmediated
CyberJournalist: News Weblogs
BoingBoing
Ms. Magazine blogroll
What She Said!
Southern New England bloggers (Gone, but here are its links)
blogdex
Metafilter
Slashdot
Slashdot Politics
Blog Sisters
Shell Extension City
Daypop Top 40 Links
Lost Remote
Mirror project
I Want Media
Blogcritics
Microcontent News
E-Media Tidbits
Through the Viewfinder
Daily Rotation
news we can use
Popdex
Blog Search Engine

Bloggers
Jim Romenesko
Shelley Powers
Doc Searls
JD Lasica
Tom Mangan
Tom Matrullo
Tom Shugart
Kevin Moore
Rebecca Blood
Cory Doctorow
David Weinberger
Lou Josephs
Dan Gillmor
Making Light
Jeneane Sessum
Liz Donovan
Robot Wisdom
Grow-a-brain
J-Walk
Dave Winer
"Salam Pax"
Baghdad Burning
Ft. Boise
Henry Gould
Wayne Robins
FollowMe Here
kalilily time
Judy Watt
Obscure Store
plep
wood s lot
The Shifted Librarian

NASA image links
Multimedia gallery
Image exchange (search)
JSC Digital Image