Comments
on this post

J. Zuckerman on Faye: Not a happy ending

Brenda G. on Faye: Not a happy ending

mb on Faye: Not a happy ending

Karen on Faye: Not a happy ending

Heidi Hartzell on Faye: Not a happy ending

Miriam on Faye: Not a happy ending



To comment on any posting, click on the word 'Comments' at the end of the item.


  ProJo.com
  ProJo Faye & Mel in NOLA
  by Faye Zuckerman and Melanie Chitwood

« Mel and Coco | Main

April 25, 2006

Faye: Not a happy ending

Back at work on Monday, April 24, I’m still trying to sort out all that I experienced in NOLA. I’m thrilled to discover that a Pulitzer Prize-winning reporter from New Orleans’ major daily newspaper, the Times Picayune, is giving a seminar on fine-tuning writing skills.

The reporter, Brian Thevenot, covered the storm and post-K New Orleans. I’m hoping he will have ideas on how to write this last posting. I’m desperate for closure.

He starts his seminar with photos from Katrina. His shots are oh-so-familiar -– collapsed houses, crushed cars, debris-filled streets and mold-infested interiors. But I know that snapshots don’t tell the true story. They can’t show the human turmoil or the extent of the devastation – miles and miles of destroyed lives.

To understand post-K, you have to see it for yourself. Everybody needs to view the scope of this life-changing storm. Such a hurricane could hit anywhere in the U.S., and wipe out any city. It just hit in New Orleans first. Katrina is a wake-up call.

Brian tells the group of Providence Journal reporters that every story needs to have a happy ending. We challenge him a bit. He recoils, and says that he’s not telling us it has to be hearts and flowers.

I search my brain for something that sparks the feeling of riding off into the sunset. I think of all the Disney movies I’ve ever seen. None of those endings apply here. When I think about NOLA, I get a sick feeling in my stomach like the one you have when you were a kid and viewed the death of Bambi’s mom.

I stepped into the middle of a tragic tale. When I left, nothing had changed. There were no resolutions, no improvement and no happy endings on the horizon.

I decide that ending on a happy note is out of reach for me. I can’t find one ounce of happiness in what I experienced. ``So, I’ll end it on a hopeful note,’’ I think.

There’s always hope. Nope. None of that either.

All I found were people in limbo and living at their wits’ end. They crowded into trailers as their nearly destroyed homes are put back together in what seems like slow motion. Or some are in apartments waiting to hear if their homes can be salvaged. Most have lost everything except the clothes they were wearing the day Katrina hit.

To me, the area can only be described as hell on Earth. It’s a valley of despair. It’s a place where people are waiting for our government to decide their futures. Can their homes – lives — be restored? Will it ever be what it was?

When did Katrina hit? Late August. What’s today’s date?

In the meantime, all the people in NOLA can do is work in the sweltering heat dragging their belongings to the curb for pick-up. Their memories litter the streets where their children once learned how to ride a bike.

I think about the E.C., where Mel and I toiled in the kitchen. Are they making a difference? I search for the latest news on what is going on in the camp. Perhaps I'll find a happy ending there.

E.C. is moving to Plaquemines Parish, some two hours from New Orleans. Once it's gone from St. Bernard Parish, where will the residents who are working on their homes receive sustenance, clothing and have access to e-mail?

The southern and eastern portion of Plaquemines Parish had a pre-storm population of about 16,000. So far, only 1,000 have returned. That parish suffered 27 levee breaks and 6.5 million gallons of spilled oil.

I set out on this journey to make a difference. I return feeling unsatisfied, and wishing I could have done more. I’m frustrated because so little has been done nine months later. There's no closure.

Please remember the need still exists in the Gulf Coast. And let’s not forget it any time soon.

Some additional photos:


clearing.jpg

debris.jpg

hole.jpg

line.jpg

Posted by Faye Zuckerman  at 8:43 PM | Permalink

Comments

You may feel guilt that you and Mel can go back to your life where your home is unravaged, your family intact, and your dreams unshattered. You may fear that this can happen anytime, anywhere, and understand that life is so vulnerable. You must feel great sadness that the rebuilding is so slow, and the human suffering so great. I am grateful that you let us share your experience. I am certain that your new NOLA friends will never forget you.
Miriam

Posted by: Miriam at April 25, 2006 09:20 PM

Faye,
I too left EC in March feeling the exact same way you do: frustrated and confused as to why it still looks like Katrina hit NOLA only a day ago. I've decided to go back in May. Your last words of the column are exactly what I say to people here in RI all the time-they really still need help. I am afraid that a lot has been forgotten and I feel so glad you took the time and your journalist talent to help us remember.

Posted by: Heidi Hartzell at April 25, 2006 09:51 PM

Faye, you HAVE made a difference ... the people you met know you care, and that you were willing to be there with them and for them!!! That's truly extraordinary. ~Karen

Posted by: Karen at April 25, 2006 10:01 PM

You now write as one who has seen the wrath of the K-beast first hand. And you can't shake it. That helpless feeling eats away at your spirit. Happy ending? Very hard. I was one to always look at the glass half full. But that's been hard after seeing my hometown NOLA post-K. Optimism can only take you so far when you are constantly beat up by the daily hassles of reclaiming your home, your life. Happy ending? I don't think there will be one until those in positions of power who have closed their eyes to the disaster, open them up and do what's right for the people, not themselves. In the mean time perhaps we can help create happy beginnings in whatever form possible for NOLA and Gulf Coast folks. You and Mel certainly did your part in helping to do that--admirably. Thank you both for your generous gift of time and talents to help. You inspire me to come up with more new beginnings to help my friends and relatives back home.

Posted by: mb at April 25, 2006 10:52 PM

Faye, It is way too soon to digest all you have experienced in post-Katrina NOLA. The physical services and clean up required must have seemed like shoveling sand against the tide; the magnitude of human suffering overwhelming. But take heart that your and Mel's help, like the help of so many other volunteers, have made a difference to each of the lives you touched in NOLA. The fact is, the restoration and normalization of people's lives and property in NOLA will only be accomplished over time, one step at a time. But the spirit of caring and compassion you and Mel brought with you to NOLA will be remembered and, I believe, forever cherished, by those whose lives you touched. Thank you for allowing us to share your experience in NOLA.

Posted by: Brenda G. at April 25, 2006 11:56 PM

A beautifully written concluding article.
You and Mel experienced a few days in your lives which will be retained in your memories forever.
I'm so proud of you both. D & G.

Posted by: J. Zuckerman at April 26, 2006 11:38 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)


faye thumb.jpg
Over spring break,
Faye B. Zuckerman, a features writer for The Providence (R.I.) Journal, and her 12-year-old daughter, Melanie Chitwood, a sixth grader at Barrington Middle School, are volunteering at a relief kitchen in New Orleans.

ProJo Faye & Mel in NOLA
Apr 2006 »
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30            

Archived headlines