« School bus drivers tell tales of snow woe / Photo | Today | Update: Seeking answers to snowstorm strandings »

December 14, 2007

M. Charles Bakst: Angry Roberts raises storm over storm

roberts.jpg Journal photo / Steve Szydlowski
Lt. Gov. Elizabeth Roberts criticizes the governor's staff at a news conference this morning.


You saw a different side of Lt. Gov. Elizabeth Roberts today, and it likely impressed you, because, in a controlled fury, she was saying exactly what you were thinking:
The government messed up in yesterday’s storm. Big time.

“Like every Rhode Islander, what I saw yesterday I never want to see again,’’ she declared at a news conference.

This was not the policy wonk or the cheerful face that are more familiar aspects of Roberts’ persona. This was one furious woman, and, by the way, an ambitious politician with a great chance to make a splash and score points.

Reporters flocked to Roberts’ office, drawn by the prospect of political bashing — an aspiring Democratic gubernatorial candidate vs. the term-limited, absent Republican governor — played out against the backdrop of a fresh, raw experience all Rhode Islanders shared. Roberts likened the state’s handling of the situation to a “debacle” or a “catastrophe,’’ a touch melodramatic, perhaps — though not if you had a kid stranded for hours on a bus.

-- Journal political columnist M. Charles Bakst

Roberts groused that Carcieri administration officials rebuffed her offers of assistance and her advice that the state Emergency Operations Center be activated.

She said, “This is New England. We have snow. I understand we can’t control nature. The timing of the storm was difficult. But we should be able to respond to a situation like this more effectively.’’

You perhaps thought Carcieri’s Iraq/Kuwait trip made Roberts acting governor. But a 1992 constitutional amendment deleted wording that put the lieutenant governor in charge whenever Number One was out of state. Indeed, Roberts said she hadn’t known Carcieri was going away until she saw news accounts that he was already abroad.

No one can know for certain how much of an impact Roberts might have made had Carcieri aides been more welcoming yesterday. She said she could have assisted in coordinating and communicating. “The public in a situation like this wants to know who’s in charge, wants to know what’s happening.’’

It’s no surprise to me that a GOP administration would keep a Democratic lieutenant governor at arm’s length. Hello, this is politics.

Roberts said she tries to work across party lines. “I don’t think this is the kind of situation where we stand on turf. I think this is the kind of situation where [it’s]‘all hands on deck.’’

To blunt Roberts’ attack, the administration offered a tableau of several officials, including Transportation director Jerome Williams. But the news conference was short on star power. The first words, from someone you wouldn’t recognize in a million years, were, “Good morning, my name is Brian Stern. I’m Governor Carcieri’s chief of staff.’’

Stern said, “Governor Carcieri and I share the frustration and anger of every Rhode Islander.’’
Hmm. You might think, “Great! SO WHY DIDN’T YOU DO A BETTER JOB IN THE FIRST PLACE?’’

Stern & Co. tried to put the best face on the situation: It snowed hard, schools and businesses emptied, there really were plows out there, Roberts’ help wasn’t needed because by then things were getting better etc.

And maybe the governor’s guys had a point. But I don’t imagine many Rhode Islanders were in the mood to hear what must have come across as bureaucratic excuse-making.

This was a day for citizens to vent about Team Carcieri’s performance, and Elizabeth Roberts was more than willing to do it on their behalf.

Posted by Karen Bordeleau  at 4:00 PM | Permalink

Comments

Leaders could have made provisions so that every commuter and the entire fleet of schoolbuses were not getting onto the road at the same time. Horrible everywhere? Sure, but everything can be improved. For the amount we pay in taxes, we can make a few small demands.

J.C. | December 14, 2007 4:54 PM link

Charlie Bask is so wrong on this! What is the point of the Lt Governor in this state then? If anything Ms Roberts has tried to use a bad situation to her advantage. Exactly, where was any of her leadership in this? Its very easy for those to criticize when they have shown zero action themselves.

Adrianna | December 14, 2007 8:49 PM link

The roads simply froze very quickly and drivers could not move,I was in it for 2 1/2 hours and people at red lights with almost no hills could not move , so how were the buses and plows supposed to get through ?? Blame NATURE!!!!

Anthony Ciccarone | December 14, 2007 8:59 PM link

Isn't it nice being a politician - just complain and never be responsible.

Paul | December 14, 2007 10:29 PM link

Roberts was smart enough to know she could not help and if she surfaced she would have to accept blame so did the courageous thing and went underground till it was over then threw stones.
Another great leader in the tradition of Jack Read ,Sheldon Whitehouse and Patrick Kennedy

Joe | December 14, 2007 11:40 PM link

If the Lt Governor "never wants to see anything like this again" I suggest she move to Palm Springs.

She chastises the administration - and the governor, who happened to be out of the country - for not doing an efficient job in handling the snowstorm. Yet she offers no information on how she would have made a difference had she stepped in to oversee the situation. Virtually all schools and businesses let students and employees leave AT THE SAME TIME. There was a tremendous surge in traffic - all of it crawling the streets and highways. What was she going to do, fly in helicopters?

DOT was doing their job with plows and people were driving cautiously. Even so,delays were inevitable. In my opinion this comes down to Elizabeth Roberts having her panties in a bunch because she wasn't allowed to lead the effort in dealing with the storm. She was seeking political gain, plain and simple.

Stephen | December 15, 2007 7:23 AM link

Post a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

ADVERTISING



ProJo 7 to 7
Nov « Dec 2007 » Jan
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    
Archived headlines

Archived
ProJo 9 to 5 News Blog
Oct 2005 - March 2006