« Photo: Coach Belichick is back at it | Today | ALERT: Buddy's finally a free man »

July 27, 2007

Lifespan, Care New England to merge / Photo

HOSPITALS 01 BM.JPG
Journal photo / Bill Murphy
Alfred Verrecchia (left) chairman of the board of directors of Lifespan, and George Vecchione (right), president and CEO of Lifespan, discuss the merger of Lifespan and Care New England, this morning.


The two hospital groups in Rhode Island, Lifespan and Care New England, have agreed once again to merge, proposing to create a seven-hospital conglomerate that would control two-thirds of hospital services in the state and establish an academic medical center at Rhode Island Hospital.

Hospital officials, whose plans face a gauntlet of federal and state reviews, envision a united system able to compete with the Boston medical centers in attracting medical researchers, winning grants and offering top-quality care. Coupled with Brown University’s plan to build a new medical school near Rhode Island Hospital, they describe the new organization as a boost to the state’s economy and biotechnology industry.

But they will have to convince regulators and the community that their union will not monopolize the market, threaten the financial health of the outlying community hospitals, or raise the health care costs.

The two corporations had come close to a similar union seven years ago, despite opposition from business and labor, and then mysteriously walked away from the deal after working on it for 23 months.

Officials dismissed the previous plans as “irrelevant” to the recent decision. While last time the focus was on efficiencies and cost-savings, this time the talk is all about investment and expansion. Unlike last time, both groups are financially strong and engaged in massive building projects. Additionally, they have a fully developed definitive agreement, which has been quietly in the works for a year.

“It’s not about cuts or layoffs. This is about growing the business,” said George Vecchione, Lifespan’s president and chief executive officer. “Trying to grow research dollars takes great coordination.”

“We hope it generates excitement and enthusiasm rather than concern,” said John J. Hynes, Vecchione’s counterpart at Care New England.

Plans call for selling or developing the highly valuable 110-acre campus of Butler Hospital, on the East Side of Providence, which the city last year assessed at $115.8 million. The proceeds would be used to build a new psychiatric hospital at Rhode Island Hospital and endow a brain science institute there, furthering Butler’s ground-breaking work in surgery to treat psychiatric conditions.

Additionally, a Level 2 trauma center would be established at Kent Hospital, in Warwick, to provide an alternative and backup to the state’s only trauma center, at Rhode Island Hospital -- a step considered crucial to preparing for disaster that might occur at or near Rhode Island Hospital.

-- Journal medical writer Felice J. Freyer

The hospitals must still prove to federal regulators that their merger would not be an illegal monopoly, and win approval from the state Health Department and the attorney general. But if they succeed, a united Lifespan and Care New England would become not just the biggest health-care organization in the state, but the biggest company of any kind doing business chiefly in Rhode Island. Its annual patient revenues would approach $2 billion; its employees would number 17,600.

Lifespan encompasses the state’s biggest hospital, Rhode Island Hospital, as well as Miriam Hospital, also in Providence, Bradley Hospital, a children’s psychiatric hospital in East Providence, and Newport Hospital.

Care New England consists of Women & Infants Hospital, in Providence, where the majority of Rhode Island babies are born; Kent Hospital, in Warwick; and Butler Hospital, a psychiatric hospital in Providence.

All the hospitals are not-for-profit.

The new organization would be called Lifespan and Vecchione would remain as CEO. Hynes would become senior vice president for special projects.

The combination would bring together five of the seven hospitals affiliated with the Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, coming closer to creating the “academic medical center” that Brown has long craved.

But the six hospitals left out of the new Lifespan include the most financially vulnerable in the state. Every one of the six lost money last year, and Landmark Medical Center in Woonsocket is amid a particularly deep financial crisis. How the merger will affect those hospitals’ viability is likely to be a top concern for regulators.

Vecchione revealed that Lifespan is “having exploratory discussions” about acquiring Landmark. The decision will hinge, in part, on whether Landmark would increase Lifespan’s market share enough to breach antitrust laws.

As the news of the merger, rumored for weeks, began to eke out today, reaction was wary and restrained.

The state’s two largest health insurers, which could face tougher negotiations over reimbursement rates with a united hospital system, both said it was too soon to comment.

Dr. Barry Wall, president of the Rhode Island Medical Society, called the merger a symptom of problems in the health care system. “This looks like it’s going to change the landscape. I think a change in landscape is a sign of trouble,” Wall said. “I don’t think beyond that anybody can say anything.”

Michael Healey, spokesman for Attorney General Patrick C. Lynch, whose office must approve the merger, said that Lynch “believes that although these institutions are extremely important, they’re still not as important as the people they serve.” Healey noted that “a ton” of work remains to be done before the merger can go through.

Rick Brooks, director of the United Nurses and Allied Professionals, the union that represents 2,000 nurses and technical workers at Rhode Island Hospital, said that the merger would require greater accountability by the hospitals.

“These hospitals really belong to the people of Rhode Island,” he said. “They don’t belong to any one person or any one company.”

Louis R. Giancola, president of South County Hospital, one of the community hospitals that will not be part of the new Lifespan, said it was too soon to predict what effect the merger would have on his institution. But he agreed with Wall that it was a sign of trouble.

“It demonstrates how challenged community hospitals, including Kent, are -- that this kind of combination is necessary to be able to continue to serve their community,” Giancola said.

Kent, which is part of Care New England, has been struggling financially and some observers see the merger as an attempt to rescue Kent.

Hynes, however, said that merger would not involve infusions of cash to Kent, and that Kent was expected to improve through administrative changes already under way.

Posted by Mike McKinney  at 12:21 PM | Permalink

Comments

Poor, poor Rhode Island. You need to get rid of Lifespan, not expand it.

Chuck | July 27, 2007 3:04 PM link

Looks like another backroom deal in the State of Rhode Island. If the Hospitals belong to the people then I think the people should have a choice which hospitals we want to go to. One hospital system certainly sounds like a monopoly to me. Doesn't anyone think "Life Span" might possibly have another mission? Gee, I wonder what that may be with only a few other hospitals remaining.

Kathy | July 27, 2007 3:48 PM link

God, please save us from total disaster. What is your agenda Lifespan? You do have one. Perhaps you should consult with the people. After all, we are the patients.

Carol | July 27, 2007 3:57 PM link

No matter what they do:
There's NO saving Kent!

Oscar the Cat | July 27, 2007 4:44 PM link

How having a one hospital system in this state is good for the people is beyond me! It smells of monopoly, anti-trust and just plain bad medicine. What kind of recourse will patients and families have? None.
I think I may be going outside the state for future medical care if things like this are allowed to happen.

Cindee | July 27, 2007 4:46 PM link

Controlling health care costs is one of the greatest issues of the times. Will this merge do that, or will various businessmen & women walk away with hefty golden parachutes & retirement plans?

Wilbur | July 27, 2007 4:50 PM link

Let's look what could be gained for our state in terms of medical care. The Lifespan system already has state of the art equipment and a top of the line medical staff. The merging of W&I into the system adds even more of the same. Competition to recruit top doctors in a specialized field is tough, and in RI the insurance industry makes it even tougher (a whole other blog). But Lifespan does have doctors renowned in their field. There are now many more reasons to seek traumatic medical care right here in RI instead of going to Mass. or Conn. The expertise is here, we need as a state to be able to further recruit more highly qualified physicians AND nurses to live and work here. It could some day very much matter to you or a loved one. It behooves Lifespan as a whole to treat and pay their employees accordingly, and it seems they do. Just food for thought.

ml | July 27, 2007 5:52 PM link

Labor, which accounts for 80% of health care costs, is so heavily unionized in Rhode Island that the Lifespan-Care New England merger is needed to get a handle on this important problem. Otherwise, the unions will do to health care in Rhode Island what they have done to the automobile industry in Detroit. Only we won't be able to look to the Japanese for our health care.

john | July 27, 2007 6:19 PM link

Labor, which accounts for 80% of health care costs, is so heavily unionized in Rhode Island that the Lifespan-Care New England merger is needed to get a handle on this important problem. Otherwise, the unions will do to health care in Rhode Island what they have done to the automobile industry in Detroit. Only we won't be able to look to the Japanese for our health care.

john | July 27, 2007 6:19 PM link

Just another example of the rich in this state wanting to be richer and not caring about the patients or employees who work at these hospitals.

Jamie | July 27, 2007 9:04 PM link

Post a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

ADVERTISING



ProJo 7 to 7
Jun « Jul 2007 » Aug
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    
Archived headlines

Archived
ProJo 9 to 5 News Blog
Oct 2005 - March 2006