« Salve Regina president joins Beacon board | Today | Carcieri to name new state fire marshal tomorrow »

May 8, 2006

StationBlog: Biechele hearing ends for today

PROVIDENCE -- After 21 statements from emotional relatives of Station fire victims, today's sentencing hearing for Daniel M. Biechele is over.

Superior Court Judge Francis J. Darigan concluded today's session at around 4 p.m. Thirteen victims' relatives spoke this morning, and another eight addressed the judge this afternoon, with Biechele, the man who ignited the pyrotechnics that started the nightclub blaze, looking on.

Sentencing proceedings will continue tomorrow morning at 10 a.m. Lawyers from the attorney general's office will read 19 statements from victims' family members in the morning session, while as many as 10 more relatives will appear in the afternoon.

Darigan is exepcted to issue a sentence on Wednesday afternoon. Biechele is facing up to 10 years in prison, after pleading guilty to 100 counts of manslaughter.

Click on "continue reading" for reports on what each speaker said at today's sentencing hearing for Daniel Biechele in The Station nightclub fire case. Biechele pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the wake of the Feb. 20, 2003, blaze in West Warwick, which killed 100 people.

'I knew I would never see him alive'
Posted 4:55 p.m.

Evelyn King feels blessed to have had her husband, Tracy, in her life, even if his life was cut short at 39 years.

"His memory is a reminder to live our lives to the fullest," said Mrs. King, the final speaker in a long, emotional day, as the sentencing hearing for Daniel Biechele began.

She recalled frantically calling her husband's cell phone on the night of the fire, hoping against all odds he had escaped the fire safely.

"Once I realized the severity of the fire, I knew I would never see him alive. I knew that my husband would never leave the building if there were people inside."

Tracy King was from Warwick.

Mrs. King says she's relieved she has been spared a trial, because Biechele pleaded guilty to 100 counts of involuntary manslaughter.

"I can only hope that others do the same," she said.

Club owners Jeffrey and Michael Derderian are the only others to have been charged in the case. They are each awaiting trial on 200 counts of manslaughter.

Before the hearing, Mrs. King told her son Jacob she was going to the sentencing.

"So, the man who killed my dad is going to jail. How long is he going to jail for?" her son asked.

"I told him that he’s not the only one going to jail, there are others," she said. "I do hope the state of Rhode Island dutifully enforces the laws."


'I ask that the court system provide the proper justice'

Gina Russo survived The Station fire, but she lost her fiance, Alfred Crisostomi, 38, of Providence.

After awaking from a coma, she learned "the person I loved and planned to marry was dead."

Russo spent four months in the hospital and endured 45 surgeries. She said 40 percent of her body is covered by burns.

She said her fiance was "taken away by somebody without any common sense."

"I ask that the court system provide the proper justice for the lives that were taken away from us," she said.


'I'm here to relate what Jimmy might say'

James Gahan III believes his 21-year-old son would have wanted "some measure of mercy," so that's what he requested from Judge Francis Darigan during a brief address this afternoon.

James Gahan, of Falmouth, Mass., was 21 when he died on that terrible night in February 2003.

"I'm here to relate what I believe Jimmy might say if he was here today," his father said.

"We pray that calmed and wiser heads than ours can appreciate the depth of our loss, the sorrow we feel, and at the same time, balance that with some measure of mercy," his father said.

"I feel Jimmy would like it that way."


'Terrified of leaving the house'
Posted 3:22 p.m.

PROVIDENCE -- Pills help Diane Mattera get through the days and nights now that she's lost her daughter Tammy.

"I take one pill so I can get out of bed in the morning. And another so I can sleep at night," Mrs. Mattera told Judge Francis Darigan.

And she's not the only one to feel the pain.

Tammy Mattera-Housa, 29, of Warwick, left behind a son, who is now 9. He's been disruptive in school, according to his grandmother.

"Is there any wonder?" she said.

One of Tammy's sisters had a scholarship to Boston University. After the Tammy's death, "she tried to go back to school – she became terrified of leaving the house, afraid that one of us wouldn’t be there when we got back," Mrs. Mattera said.

She ended up taking the semester off, but never went back.

A brother has dropped out of high school.

"When you lose someone, people tell you things will get easier as time passes," Mrs. Mattera said. "They lie. Time passes, but the pain and the loss are always there."

'I miss her every day'

Linda Dalton wishes she could get one more hug from her sister.

Judith Manzo, 37, of North Providence, a mother of two, was her best friend and "always gave the best hugs."

"I miss her every day."

'You'll see her in the morning'
Posted 3:22 p.m.

PROVIDENCE -- Laura Gillett was the mother of two boys, Jake, who was 6, and Jared, who was 3 when their mother died.

Laura's mother, Peg Paterno, recalled how Jared woke up twice asking for his mom on the night she died.

“I said go to sleep, 'You’ll see her in the morning,' " Mrs. Paterno said.

Now there are only photographs and memories.

"We go to the boys baseball games now and think about how much Laura would have liked to be there, too," Mrs. Paterno said.

Mrs. Paterno thinks about her daughter when she sees other little boys running up to their moms.

Jared and Jake's mom was just 32 when she died.

After Laura's death, her parents developed film from Laura's camera. There were pictures of the last day she spent with her boys. They had gone sledding.

'That would be the last kiss'
Posted 3:05 p.m.

Twenty-one-year-old Leigh Ann Moreau wore a light blue sweater that "matched her eyes" the night she went out to The Station nightclub.

"My wife remembers the look on her face as she adjusted her hair and clothing," Leigh's father, Richard Moreau said this afternoon.

"She asked her mother, 'Do I look OK?' "

Before going out, she kissed her mother on the cheek "as she always did," Moreau recalled.

"Little did my wife know that would be the last kiss," he said.

Leigh, a December 2002 college graduate who majored in art therapy, had planned to spend the evening with her boyfriend, Mark Fontaine.

With his arm around his wife, Richard Moreau cried as he spoke. He said many people must be held accountable for the fire that claimed the life of his daughter and her boyfriend.

The owners of the nightclub, Jeffrey and Michael Derderian, are the only others to have been charged in relation to the fire. They each face 200 counts of manslaughter. Their trials are pending.

Meanwhile, Richard Moreau says, "We know we will never adjust to life without Leigh."

She feels 'overwhelming physical pain'
Posted 3:05

The pain Susan Howorth Pritchard feels after losing her brother in The Station nightclub fire is not just emotional, but physical.

As statements from friends and family members of people killed in the fire resumed this afternoon in Superior Court, Pritchard was the first to tell Judge Francis Darigan about her loss. Thirteen people addressed the court this morning.

Pritchard's only brother, Carlton “Bud” Howorth III, 39, of Norton, Mass., died in the fire.

She gets migraine headaches. At the holidays or whenever she's reminded of him, she feels "overwhelming physical pain."

"We can’t figure out how to make it go away," she said. "The pain is intellectual, emotional and phsycial for us."

"I feel like what’s been taken is 50 years of happiness," she said.

ted 12:30

Michael and Sandy Hoogasian walked down the aisle together and later died together at The Station nightclub.

Friends and family members lost not just one, but two people they loved.

"Do you know what it's like to have two people you love so much die in such a horrific manner they can only be identified by dental records?" Michael's sister, Paula A. McLaughlin said.

"Have you ever had to call your little brother's and sister's cell phones over and over again, until they were shut off, just so you could hear their voices?"

"Do you know what it's like to wake up 1,142 days later in complete sadness saying I can't believe they're not here?"

“Today is day 1,142 of our never ending nightmare.”

Michael, 31, and Sandy, 27, were from Cranston.

Sandy's brother asked for the maximum allowable sentence.

He said he appreciated that Daniel Biechele has cooperated, but that he made a conscious decision to set off the pyrotechnics.

-- projo.com staff writers Kate Bramson and Steve Peoples

Sentencing hearing's first morning concludes
Posted: 12:18 p.m.

PROVIDENCE -- The first morning of a sentencing hearing for Daniel Biechele in The Station fire case has concluded.

Statements from victims' families on the impact of the fire that killed 100 people will continue this afternoon at 2:30 p.m. in Superior Court.

Nine people are scheduled to be heard, after 13 this morning over about two hours.

Biechele pleaded guilty to 100 counts of manslaughter in the 2003 nightclub blaze. He will be sentenced on Wednesday afternoon after another day of statements from victims' families tomorrow.


'I lost my first born and my best friend'
Posted: 12:07 p.m.

PROVIDENCE -- John Michael Longiaru, 23, of Johnston, planned to become a writer.

"We will never know all that John would have become," his mother said this morning.

He was a former class president and an avid reader.

"We will never hear, 'I love you,' and he always said that. We will never see John's big beautiful smile as he walks in the door, his arms open wide, just to give you a great big hug."

Our lives are changed forever," she said adding that she cannot sleep more than two hours a night.

"I miss my reading partner so much," she said. "Since John died, I cannot read anymore."

She said, "I lost my first born and my best friend."

'We have been sentenced to life without parole'
Posted 11:55 a.m.

Eileen DiBonaventura kept waiting for a phone call telling her that her son Albert Anthony DiBonaventura was all right.

“The call we prayed for never came,” she said, crying, her husband standing next to her.

Their 18-year-old son, of North Dighton, Mass., had died in the fire. They needed dental records to identify him.

“We need for the court to realize the overwhelming devastation we have been forced to endure since this needless tragedy," she said.

She said there's no excuse for those responsible for the fire.

“A parents’ worst nightmare had come true for us. Why did this have to happen?”

“We have been sentenced to life without parole," she said. "Our lives are incomplete and lonely.”


'Time has not begun to touch the pain'
Posted 11:55 a.m.

PROVIDENCE -- Tina Ayer's twin sister, Tammy, still feels anger toward Daniel Biechele and others she considers responsible for the fire that caused Tina's death.

Tammy said her sister, a 33-year-old Warwick resident, was "a beautiful sister, daughter, mom."

"They say time will heal all wounds," Tammy said. "I'm living proof that time has not begun to touch the hurt or pain we feel.

"Your honor, there is nothing more painful in life than to bury your only child," William C. Bonardi told Judge Francis J. Darigan Jr.


'A part of us died with him.'
Posted 11:55 a.m.

With his wife at his side, Bonardi told Darigan that his namesake William C. “Billy” Bonardi III, 36, of Smithfield was their only son.

"A part of us died with him," he said.

He didn't live long enough to give them grandchildren.

"This horrific tragedy also destroyed our family name," he said. "Bonardi will no longer exist."

He said their son was "loved by many," and the couple will never get over his death.

"We lost our best creation, and our future."


The struggle before court
Posted 11:46 a.m.

PROVIDENCE -- How do you condense a life of 34 years into five minutes?

That's the task that faced Anna Gruttadauria when she tried preparing a victim-witness impact statement about her daughter Pamela Ann Gruttadauria.

During a break outside the courtroom this morning, Mrs. Gruttadauria said it took her two months to decide what to say.

Getting up there and talking was scary, she said.

Pamela was her life, she said outside the courtroom. Time hasn't healed her wounds. If anything, it's gotten worse, she said.

The stories from family members of other victims made her and her sister, Tina Florio, cry she said.

Florio said, "I hate when people say, 'This is closure.' It never is."


'Joy disappeared with Mark's death'
Posted: 11:34 a.m.

PROVIDENCE -- Rosanna Fontaine, mother of fire victim Mark Adam Fontaine, 22, rushed to the The Station nightclub after receiving a call from her distraught daughter.

It was 11:23 p.m. She and her husband were there for hours, "searching frantically for our children and not finding them."

She saw three firefighters covered in soot. All three were sobbing.

That's when she realized how bad it was.

"Our home was filled with laughter and joy. The laughter stopped and the joy disappeared with Mark’s death."


Dad never got to say goodbye

Leland Hoisington never got to say goodbye to his daughter Abbie Hoisington, 28, of Cranston.

She was a special education teacher in Burrillville.

"Her students adored her," he said.

"One of student's mothers came up to me at the funeral and said, ‘Your daughter changed my daughter's life. She hated school. Now she loves school.’ "

"I have the last card she sent to me for my birthday. It said, 'I’ll always be daddy’s little girl.' "

She sent it three weeks before she died.

"I never did get to say goodbye," he said. "I never did get to tell her I loved her."


'All I could do was hug her and cry.'
Posted 11:13 a.m.

PROVIDENCE -- Jessica Garvey struggled to comfort her mother over the loss of Jessica's sister, Dina A. DeMaio, 30, of West Warwick.

"I remember finally getting there and sitting by my mother," she said. "She put her arms around me and I didn’t know what to say."

"All I could do was hug her and cry."


No forgiveness in her heart

Suzanne Fox wants people to be held accountable for the death of her son, Jeffrey W. Martin, 33, of Melrose, Mass.

“There is not a shred of forgiveness in my heart," she said. "I miss my son more than I ever could have imagined."

"Jeff was my bright star.”


'Our family will always be incomplete'
PROVIDENCE -- The death of Thomas Medeiros, 40, of Coventry, means, "Our family will always be incomplete," said Andrea M. Silva, a niece.

"There was not a day he did not spend time with one of his brothers or sisters. The boys talk about him often," she said, referring to Medeiros' 4-year-old nephews.

"How do you tell 4-year-olds their uncle died in the worst fire in state history?"

"How do you express such pain?'
Posted 10:20 a.m.
biech1.jpg
Journal photo / Steve Szydlowski
Patricia Belanger, of Richmond, comforts Timothy Miceli, brother of Station nightclub fire victim Samuel Miceli, at a break this morning in the first day of the sentencing hearing for Daniel Biechele, who pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the wake of the blaze, which killed 100 people.


Even after three years, Timothy Miceli had trouble putting into words the pain of losing his brother, Samuel A. Miceli, 37, of Lisbon, Conn.

"How do you express in words such pain? How do you define a loss so great?," Timothy Miceli asked, crying. "My life will never be the same again."


Struck down in the prime of her life

Anna Gruttadauria described her daughter, Pamela Ann Gruttadauria, 33, of Johnston, as a "beautiful, loving, kind woman."

"She was just starting to get her life together when she was struck down by this fire in the prime of her life," Mrs. Gruttadauria said.

Pamela became the fire's 100th victim.

"I never thought in our lives we'd be sitting by our daughter's side waiting for her to die," Mrs. Gruttadauria said.


13 to speak this morning
hearing5.jpg
Journal photo / Mary Murphy
Danield Biechele, left, appears with his attorney Tom Briody, as his sentencing hearing begins this morning in Superior Court in Providence.

Posted 9:37 a.m.

Superior Court Judge Francis Darigan will take the victim-impact statements into consideration when he imposes a sentence on Daniel M. Biechele, the 29-year-old band manager who set off the fireworks that started The Station fire nightclub blaze.

Biechele pleaded guilty to 100 counts of involuntary manslaughter in February and faces up to 10 years in prison.

The tragic fire, which killed 100 people and injured 200 more in February 2003, captured the nation's attention. Court TV plans to provide gavel-to-gavel coverage of the sentencing hearing over the next three days. Television trucks are parked outside the Licht Judicial Complex on 250 Benefit St.

Here is a list of those scheduled to speak at this morning's session: (The first name is the deceased. The second is the speaker.)

-- With reports from projo.com staff writers Kate Bramson and Steve Peoples

Posted by Jack Perry  at 4:41 PM | Permalink

Comments

I grew up with Tracy King and his brothers. They were a very close knit family. My heart goes out to his mother Shirley,who will never be the same, brought those boys up to be great men, fathers, husbands, who respected everyone and would do anything for anyone. What I would like to know is if all people involve are charged, tried, and convicted, then why isn't the WEST WARWICK FIRE INSPECTOR (whose job is to make sure the buildings are up to codes) being charged, tried and convicted? He had done the inspection and pass the Station. If they are going to go after the one who set the fireworks, then they should go after the one who inspected the building. Is it because he is a city official, and the city of West Warwick didn't want the embarrassment of hiring people that obviously aren't qualified for their jobs? I think if the owners and the band manager are taking their consequences, everyone involved should! We owe it to the families of the victims, to prosecute everyone that was involved, not just a select few! My thoughts and prayers are always with all the families.

gretchen stephenson | May 8, 2006 6:26 PM link

What about the West Warwick Fire Marshall that said the club was safe???? He is the one who should be charged along with everyone else...

Jen | May 9, 2006 6:39 AM link

It is heartbreaking to hear the stories of those people affected by this horrible tragedy. It was truly something that never had to happen. I think that it is important for Mr. Biechele and others to take responsibility for their irresponsible actions on the night of the fire. I only wonder if everyone would be better served if the punishment would serve a better cause. I don't think that anything is accomplished by putting these people in jail. I think that they should have to work and supplement the income of those affected. They should be confined to their homes so that their freedom is, in fact, limited. Finally they should be required to provide community service for many many years.

Melissa | May 9, 2006 11:36 AM link

I can not understand why someone/anyone should go to prison for the Station fire. Yes, people lost their lifes, BUT, it was an accident. People was at the Station to have a good time, and things went wrong. BUT not criminal. Some people talk like, that fire was set with criminal intent. God called for those who past at the Station. It was a freak accident, one that no one wants to see again. So please just think. Why should anyone go to prison for a accident. What can that solve. That's like saying lock-up the Firemen because they didn't get there fast anuff.
Thank you and God bless us all.

Maximo Deacaba | May 9, 2006 11:52 AM link

To Claire, Paula, and Donna (Mother and Sisters of Michael Hoogasian ) Michael and Sandy were taken from you and they are now in Heaven with Jesus. This terrible accident should & would not have happed if the Fire Marshall knew his job. He should be there with all the others who have let this happen. I Love You Sister-in-Law Dee Lefebvre

Dee Lefebvre | May 9, 2006 7:09 PM link

As my heart goes out to those who lost their loved ones from this tragedy my heart also goes out to those who are being tried for this tragic ACCIDENT and their families. This was a tragic accident not murder. No one was meant to die. These men are not murderers, but it seem like everyone (most of the victims families)is set on getting revenge. Am I saying they did't make mistakes?- no they did things that were wrong but if they really felt something like this was going to happen they would have taken a different course of action. I do not think these men shouldget any jail time. Community service seems appropriate but they do not deserve to be in jail.

johanna | May 10, 2006 11:49 AM link

Why in the world would anyone want to confine Danny Beichele? What is he guilty of? His only desire on the evening of the fire was to entertain fans. He never got up that morning and said..."Ok, today I'll start a big fire and end the lives of innocent people. Did anyone out there who is pointing the finger at him....ever realize that he, Daniel Beichele, is also a victim. Danny, however, will be punished twice. Once, and formost, his own actions will haunt him forever. And now ....to put him in the environment with scum...serves no purpose. It God who spared Dan's life. Believe me, there is a God, and he forgives Danny. Why can't the rest of you who keep condemning him? STOP!!! He didn't set the fire deliberately. He is a person too. What about his parents, his wife, his sister and the rest of his family....think they have not been destroyed by this? To the people who just want to continue punishing Danny.....would you feel the same had your loved one accidentally started this fire? I think not. You would be right here next to me writing as I am for forgiveness of this innocent man. Look not at him as a crimminal...as there was never any crimminal intent, ever. Please, I beg you...put your hands together and pray for him. He may not have to spend the rest of his days in jail...but, understand he has A LIFE SENTENCE.....Lastly, love one another as he has loved you....."There but for the grace of God go YOU!

kathleen mcdonald | May 11, 2006 3:14 PM link

When I watched court tv I was really moved by a father who lost his son in the fire. His son was involved in the Make A Wish foundation.Does anybody know the name of the man that died in the fire ?Please email me at clementeguy@charter.net
Thanks

Pat | September 16, 2006 3:24 PM link

Post a comment

Please be civil. Vicious comments, personal attacks and profanity won't be published. Name and email are required; email address will not publish.




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

ADVERTISING



ProJo 7 to 7
Apr « May 2006 » Jun
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31    
Archived headlines

Archived
ProJo 9 to 5 News Blog
Oct 2005 - March 2006