Vinatieri
Adam Vinatieri didn't have to win the game for the Colts, but he did make things right after his own messy start. It looked bad for the two-time Super Bowl when the first PAT was blown by a fumbled snap, and he got crunched picking up the ball. Then he hooked his first short FG. Charmed life over? Nah. His 3 short field goals made sure the Colts got something when they got close. I'd still take him if I needed a game-winner in a Super Bowl. He has 4 rings now, and made a record 14 made field goals in this postseason.